The School to Prison pipeline and the urgency of addressing teacher bias

 

Inexperienced teachers and implicit bias combine to create a dangerous influence that affects  minority children  as soon as they start preschool. According to the 2013-2014 department of education report black students are three times more likely to be suspended than white students. This bias also extends  significantly to other non white students rates of suspension. Shockingly  disparities in discipline have not improved  since the sixties  and seventies. In an  examination of racial disproportionality in school disciplinary practices William Drakeford  states that a  1975  Children’s Defense report fund found that black students were two to three times more likely to be suspended than white students.  Why have  discipline practices remained steadily more harsh for minority students? Because  teachers are not learning examine and address how their biases affect their students.   As teachers grow in their careers and  gain experience  they  becoming more effective and  the quality of the education that they can provide students improves. However,  the 2013-14 report found that  the  percent of  inexperienced first-year teachers was strongly correlated with  the percent of black and Hispanic students. Findings indicate that twice as many  first-year teachers  were employed in schools with  predominantly minority students, as compared to schools with predominantly white students.

Losing valuable instruction time, being labeled as incompetent, stupid or as a problem child can set a child up  for the school-to-prison pipeline. Disengaged  Students  are vulnerable students  and according to the Center for American Progress,  they are more likely to drop out and have  negative interactions with the criminal justice system. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Educate to Liberate: Teachers are the answer

The above title was taken from Joshua Block‘s  informative article on ways to create an anti-racist classroom.  Despite the staggering statistics  about racial disparities in the US education system,  and the difficulties of combating implicit bias, and structural racism,  there is a glimmer of hope.  That hope is  teachers. Teachers with integrity and compassion. Teachers who are working to truly like the Poudre school district mission states  “Educate Every Child Every Day.”  Teachers who understand that Every Child also means children who have the odds stacked against them because of their race.   Teachers   who are  outraged that children  are stereotyped as loud or disruptive or  incompetent  based on their race.  Teachers that understand the school to prison pipeline  is paved with good intentions. Teachers who are working to combat their own personal implicit biases. Teachers who are working to educate their peers  through online platforms, blogs and classes. like some of the great one listed below  Thanks Teachers!

https://www.edutopia.org/blog/build-an-anti-racist-classroom-joshua-block

https://www.edutopia.org/blog/keys-to-challenging-implicit-bias-shane-safir

http://www.edchange.org/multicultural/papers/racism_morgan.html

http://www.edweek.org/tm/articles/2015/04/29/a-teachers-role-in-fighting-racism.html

 

Missing the Big stuff, How Racial Education in US Schools is Failing.

The other day I overheard some classmates( in an upper division undergraduate class at an institution of higher learning)    discussing the New  Bill Nye the Science guy show. Bill Nye has been a popular topic of discussion in the news lately on account of his participation in the April 22 2017 March for Science and his new TV show. The conversation  caught my interest  when it turned to discussing racism. On of the speakers complained that the show seemed to be  taking one sided stances on some topics. He described an   “Indian Guy’s ” discussion of   cultural appropriation as racist,  because if  the speaker replaced “white people” with “black people” the    discussion  would become immediately unacceptable.  This  line of thinking  which is all to common, even among  educated individuals has a number of  fundamental flaws. The first being that Racism is prejudice, or  an attitude as described by  Stokely Carmichael    

Mistaking prejudice for racism is a  dangerous mistake, and one that is all to prevalent. Racism is a power structure, it cannot be  evenly applied to white people in the same way that it is applied to black people, like the  boy in my class though,  if the racial designations were just to be switched in a discussion.  How can  people  can reach their senior year in college and have no idea how racism works?  Why isn’t  the evidence based and peer reviewed,  research on racial issues  making it into US curriculum.  Why isn’t  anti-racism a strategic outcome of American Universities?   Teachers and educators across the United Sates need to seriously consider these questions.

 

 

 

How Can Teachers Address Implicit bias?

Implicit biases do not make us bad people, they are simply part of the human condition and a side effect of living in our society.  However, these unconscious beliefs can and do direct teacher’s responses and actions, and as Professor Drew Westen explains in his book, The Political Brain: The Role of Emotion in Deciding the Fate of the Nation (2007), “Irrespective of what we may feel and believe consciously, most White Americans—including many who hold consciously progressive values and attitudes—harbor negative associations toward people of color.”  Unless teachers take personal intuitive to address their own implicit bias, they will continue to remain powerful but subconscious forces that negatively affect students.

How then  teachers  combat implicit bias?  The first step is  to recognize bias.

Implicit biases are subconscious attitudes or belief that most people unaware of.  As implicit biases, especially for teachers, can often be in opposition to cherished conscious beliefs and intentions, becoming aware of them is accompanied by serious cognitive dissonance, and emotional reactions. Once aware of implicit bias many teachers may, out of worry of being labeled racist, be reluctant to acknowledge them, especially in the company of their professional peers. Unacknowledged bias is hard to address, and for this reason,  trainings offered at conferences rare not the most effective way of addressing implicit bias. Taking personal initiative to address implicit bias allow teachers the emotional space to process difficult feelings in privacy.

 

 

 

 

 

How to start Combating Implicit Bias

Combating implicit bias first requires awareness of bias.  The first step necessary to cultivate an awareness of implicit bias is realize that you, especially if you are a non-minority, have implicit biases.  Accepting that biases are a part of the human condition, that they are hardwired into minds shortly after we are born and then reinforced   through our development, our schooling and our interactions with culture and the media.  Whatever conscious beliefs about equality and diversity you may hold, whatever political party you support, or whatever charities you donate to, implicit biases are hidden in your subconscious mind. Dating or befriending someone of another race does not exempt you, nor does having bi-racial children. Fortunately tools like the Project Implicit tests,  activities based on Peggy McIntosh’s “Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack” and the AAUW’s tool  to test for unconscious associations,  are available to help us become aware of personal implicit biases.

But what do we do once we realize we have implicit biases, how do we take these subconscious drivers out of the pilot seats and consciously  live our lives  in ways that  promote equity and equality?  Researchers  Patricia G. Devine, Patrick S. Forscher, Anthony J. Austin, and William T. L. Cox from the University of Wisconsin have likened implicit bias to a habit and are working to develop a strategy based on evidence practices of transforming habits  that can work for combating bias.  Devine  determined that in order to  combat bias people need to first develop awareness of their bias and  “they must be concerned about the consequences of their biases before they will be motivated to exert effort to eliminate them.”   Hopefully you are already concerned about the negative consequences of implicit biases, but for those that do not see the urgency and importance of combating implicit bias there are a number of things that may help.  Seeking out and listening to other’s stories, travelling and interacting  with people from diverse backgrounds, and specially designed training can help to motivate people to become more  concerned about others.

 

Is examining Implicit Bias right for you?

Anyone who will ever wield any power needs to understand that   implicit biases are like puppet strings directing actions and behaviors and even thoughts without the thinker’s conscious permission.   Ideally every person needs to examine their own implicit biases, from cashiers at the grocery store, (check out the video link  for an example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wf9QBnPK6Yg) to the politicians elected to represent American citizens.

It is particularly urgent, however, that teachers, especially middle school, and high school teachers, work to examine their implicit biases. Teacher’s implicit biases have the power to affect children  in  really consequential ways.  The research behind this statement is conclusive; The Civil Rights Data Collection (CRDC), a survey collecting  data on civil rights issues  in American schools has consistently found that minority students are subjected to biases  that manifest as disparities in primary and secondary education that  have lifelong consequences for students in terms of higher education, success and self-fulfillment, and criminalization.  Evidence from the CDDC, Yale University studies  indicate that  black students are four times as likely to be suspended as white students,  twice as likely to be expelled and black preschoolers are 3.6 times more likely to receive one or more out-of-school suspensions.   Largely, white teachers are  allowing implicit bias to inform their expectations of students and influence disciplinary actions,  Teacher demographics are not keeping pace with are rapidly changing   student demographics. The US census bureau estimated that by 2020 more than half of school children in the United states will be minorities, but education Department   predictions indicate that white female will continue to make up the majority of primary and secondary teachers.   Teachers have a golden opportunity and a responsibility to address the implicit biases that contribute to disparities in how minority children are treated in school systems. The face of America is changing and teachers can   help to make that change positive and healthy for all students.Teachers can either choose to  be on the front lines of combatting racism or to unconsciously maintain the structures that perpetuate it.

Interested in getting started on the journey of examining your own implicit biases? Check out these cool materials.

Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack

“Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack” by Peggy Mcintosh is This is about understanding white privilege. It was a groundbreaking work when first published and is still 100% relevant.

First published in 1989 in the Magazine of the Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom, “Unpacking”  should be required reading for every middle schooler, high schooler and teacher in United States. The work is essentially a powerful but gentle guide to understanding structural racism and the “hidden”  privileges that having white confers on a person. I had the privilege to attend a workshop based on this material taught by McIntosh through Berea College’s   Carter G. Woodson Center.  The workshop my fist structured introduction to examining my own racial biases, and was a major inspiration that set in motion a personal mission to examine and address my own implicit biases and the manifestations of race in my life.

 Check it out: here’s a link to a pdf hosted by Washington University.  If you want to print more than 35 copies  or post the work electronically please contact to the author, Dr. Peggy McIntosh, at mmcintosh@wellesley.edu.

https://admin.artsci.washington.edu/sites/adming/files/unpacking-invisible-knapsack.pdf

 

Project Implicit:  Race Test

Project Implicit is a international collaboration between research scientists at Harvard university and across the world to gather anonymous information about implicit biases.  The project has developed a number of tests that can help people to discover  implicit biases, beliefs and attitudes that they may not be consciously aware of holding.  This is important work, as unconscious bias  can be motivating factors that influence our decisions, behaviors and treatment of others. Shockingly many people find that they have implicit bias that are in opposition to consciously held beliefs.  For example, I believe that women are as capable and effective scientists as men, but I  discovered that I had an implicit bias  against trusting scientific information from women.  Uncovering implicit biases is profoundly important for anyone who  works for social justice,  teachers, police and politicians.  I recommend anyone, especially individuals  working to combat racism to take  the race test. Though these are not perfect tests, they will help you start  the process of cutting puppet strings that may be guiding your actions without your permission.

 Check it out:  Here’s the link to project implicit, where you can find 13 tests designed to discover your implicit biases!

https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/takeatest.html

What you don’t know can hurt: Implicit bias in education.

In the light of the changing demographic trends rapidly affecting schools across the nation, issues of bias in education are being  increasingly brought to the public’s attention.  Implicit bias describes attitudes and stereotypes that unconsciously affect people’s perceptions, actions, and decisions. These are beliefs that people can hold without being consciously aware of their existence or influence. I have been interested in addressing my own explicit and implicit biases, and rooting out racism from my own mind for quite some time. This inclination is partly the result of diverse experiences as a child; attending predominantly Latino and African American schools as a white minority in Vallejo CA, having babysitters and family friends of different nationalities but also is due to having precocious reading habits as a child. I read Ralph Ellison’s “The Invisible Man”  before I was old enough to really understand it, but my first real scientific induction into implicit bias  is a direct result of attending Berea College in Kentucky and taking classes about race relations, race and gender in the media, and having  Black teachers.  Meeting bell hooks and Peggy McIntosh at Berea  College and attending a seminar based on McIntosh’s work  “White privilege, “Unpacking the  Invisible knapsack”  inspired me to examine my own implicit biases and privileges I ways that I had never considered.   The idea of unknowingly harboring biases that play behind the scenes directing roles in my actions and thoughts was frightening and really distasteful to me when I first  learned about it.   Once I began admit that reality it became increasingly easier for me to  question my behaviors  and thoughts more critically. Although I am disappointed that I had to wait until college to really begin this work, in a structured fashion, I am grateful for the opportunities for growth that higher education has afforded.